X← X · 精读长文
文章X · 精读长文· 06-22 · 12:41

没有生态的前沿是不稳定的

A frontier without an ecosystem is not stable

打开原文约 11 分钟读

I’ve been thinking a lot about the future of the firm in an AI-driven economy.

This transition is different than any previous platform shift. In the past, we used digital systems to enhance human capital. This is the first time we can create a real cognitive loop between people and digital systems. That is a mind-bender, because it changes how we even conceptualize work inside an enterprise.

What is at stake is not some digital tool or system and its use, but how organizations continue to learn, build IP, differentiate, and thrive in a world where AI models can continuously absorb the expertise of humans and organizations and commoditize it.

Every company is going to have to build what I think of as human capital and token capital. Human capital comprises the knowledge, judgment, relationships, ingenuity, and pattern recognition of its people, while token capital is the firm’s AI capability it builds and owns.

Importantly, human capital does not become less valuable as token capital grows. It only becomes more valuable! I believe human agency will be the driver of token capital growth. Humans will set ambitious goals, connect dots across domains, build relationships, and recognize patterns that matter most. Without human direction, you have compute running in circles.

This means the real opportunity is not in picking the best model but instead in building a learning loop on top of models where human capital and token capital compound. You can offload a task, or even a job, but you can never offload your learning. The future of the firm is the ability to compound that learning across people and AI.

This requires a new architectural approach where every business is able to build agentic systems that improve over time, while still retaining control over their IP. A company should be able to switch out a “generalist” model without losing the “company veteran” expertise built into their learning system. This is the key “test” of your control and sovereignty in the era ahead.

Companies need to turn their workflows, domain knowledge, and accumulated judgment into AI systems that improve with each use. Private evals should capture whether a model is actually improving against outcomes that matter to the business (not just external benchmarks!). Private reinforcement learning environments should let models grow stronger on real traces from inside the organization. Its knowledge base makes institutional memory queryable and use of tokens more efficient.

This loop becomes the new IP of the firm. I think of it as a hill climbing machine. And unlike most assets, it compounds. Every improved workflow generates better training signal, which accelerates the accumulation of tacit knowledge unique to the firm. The companies that build this early will have an advantage that is hard to replicate, regardless of any new individual model capability.

The last thing any of us want is a world where every company across every sector is ceding value to a few models that eat everything they see. If all the value is accrued by only a few models, the political economy will simply not tolerate it. There is no societal permission for an AI future that hollows out entire industries.

Think about what happened in the first phase of globalization where entire industrial economies were hollowed out by outsourcing. The GDP numbers looked fine on the surface, but the displacement was real and the consequences are still being felt. Let us not bring that dynamic into the AI era, with a small number of AI systems capturing all the economic returns, while entire industries find their knowledge commoditized right out from underneath them.

In my view, our priority has to be building a frontier ecosystem, not just a frontier model, so value flows broadly across every company, every industry, and every country. One where every organization can own the learning loop that encodes its institutional knowledge, compounding its human and token capital.

This is the ethos I’ve grown up with where platforms enable more value on top than is captured inside, and where every company can continuously innovate and build value of its own.

When that happens, companies will create value for themselves and for the economy around them. Employees will see their expertise amplified and their judgment become part of systems that make it replicable and scalable and the benefits accrue to the companies and communities around them.

That is how companies drive value for themselves and the broader economy. And it is the stable equilibrium we should build together.

这段时间,我一直在思考一个问题:在一个由 AI 驱动的经济里,企业的未来会是什么样子。

这一次转型与以往任何一次平台变迁都不同。过去,我们用数字系统去增强人的能力;而这是我们第一次能够在人与数字系统之间建立起一个真正的认知闭环。这是个会让人脑筋打结的转变,因为它改变了我们对「企业内部的工作」这件事本身的理解方式。

真正悬而未决的,不是某个数字工具、某个系统该如何使用,而是:当 AI 模型可以不断吸收人与组织的专业能力、并将其商品化,组织又该如何持续学习、积累知识产权、构建差异化,并在这样的世界里立足壮大。

每一家公司都将不得不去构建我所说的两类资本——人力资本与 token 资本。人力资本,是其员工身上的知识、判断、人脉、巧思与模式识别能力;token 资本,则是这家公司亲手构建并真正拥有的 AI 能力。

要紧的是,人力资本并不会因为 token 资本的增长而变得不那么值钱。恰恰相反,它只会更值钱!我相信,人的能动性才是 token 资本增长的真正驱动力。是人来设定远大的目标,在不同领域之间打通关节,建立关系,识别出那些最要紧的模式。没有人的指引,算力只会原地打转。

这意味着,真正的机会并不在于挑出那个最好的模型,而在于在模型之上构建一个学习闭环——在这个闭环里,人力资本与 token 资本彼此叠加、复利增长。你可以把一项任务、甚至一份工作外包出去,但你永远无法把自己的「学习」外包出去。企业的未来,正在于让这种学习在人与 AI 之间不断累积复利的能力。

要做到这一点,需要一种全新的架构思路:每一家企业都能够构建出会随时间推移而不断自我改进的智能体系统(agentic systems),同时又始终牢牢掌控自己的知识产权。一家公司应当能够换掉一个「通才」模型,而不会丢失沉淀在其学习系统里的那份「老将」经验。这正是衡量你在未来时代中掌控力与主权的关键「试金石」。

公司需要把自己的工作流、领域知识与日积月累的判断力,转化为会随每一次使用而越用越强的 AI 系统。私有评测(private evals)应当衡量一个模型是否真的在那些对业务真正重要的结果上有所长进——而不只是在外部基准测试上跑分。私有强化学习环境,应当让模型在源自组织内部的真实轨迹(traces)上不断变强。而它的知识库,让机构记忆变得可被查询,也让 token 的使用更加高效。

这个闭环,将成为企业新的知识产权。我把它想象成一台「爬山机」(hill climbing machine)。而且,与大多数资产不同,它会产生复利。每一个被改进的工作流,都会生成更好的训练信号,进而加速那些为这家公司所独有的隐性知识的累积。那些早早把这套系统建起来的公司,将拥有一种难以被复制的优势——无论日后又冒出什么新的单点模型能力,都难以撼动它。

我们当中没有人希望看到这样一个世界:每一个行业里的每一家公司,都把价值拱手让给少数几个吞噬一切所见之物的模型。如果所有价值都只归集到寥寥几个模型手中,政治经济的现实根本不会容忍这种局面。一个会把整个整个行业掏空的 AI 未来,是得不到社会许可的。

想想全球化第一阶段发生过什么——整片整片的工业经济被外包掏空。表面上看,GDP 数字依旧好看,但那种错位是真切的,其后果至今仍在被人们承受。我们不要把那一套动力机制再带进 AI 时代——让少数几个 AI 系统攫取全部的经济回报,而一个又一个行业,眼睁睁看着自己的知识就这样在脚底下被商品化掏空。

在我看来,我们的优先要务,必须是去构建一个前沿生态,而不仅仅是一个前沿模型——好让价值能够广泛地流向每一家公司、每一个行业、每一个国家。在这样的生态里,每一个组织都能拥有那个为它编码了自身机构知识的学习闭环,让它的人力资本与 token 资本一同复利增长。

这正是我成长过程中一以贯之所秉持的精神:平台让其上承载的价值,多于它自身所攫取的价值;让每一家公司都能持续创新,构建属于自己的价值。

当这一切发生时,公司将既为自己、也为身边的经济创造价值。员工会看到自己的专长被放大,自己的判断成为某种系统的一部分——这种系统让那份判断变得可复制、可规模化,而其收益,则惠及周遭的公司与社群。

这才是公司既为自己、也为更广阔的经济创造价值的方式。而这,也正是我们应当携手共建的那个稳定均衡。